Shaw Flooring vs. Mohawk Industries: An Honest Comparison

Deciding between two reputable brands seems easy, just pick one, right? Having two similar companies or products like Shaw Flooring & Mohawk makes it more difficult for major decisions like flooring and home improvement. How do you know which company is right for you? Your internet searches are likely not laying out all the facts, and you may not be much further along than when you started.

Whether you’re a homeowner, a contractor, or a designer, it’s essential to understand the differences and similarities between these two brands regarding quality, durability, and style. This article will take a closer look at both Shaw and Mohawk flooring products, their pros and cons, and what sets them apart from one another. 

The goal for us at Flooring Solutions is to provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision and choose the best flooring option for your home or business.

When you’re shopping for flooring, online or in person, you’re going to hear about all the fierce competition between brands. You’ll hear all kinds of information about one being better than the other based on information that may not mean anything to you. But in the end it’s up to one thing: what’s right for you. So let’s discuss their differences and see if you can work out which is the best company for your needs.

Who is Shaw Flooring?

Shaw Flooring is one of the largest flooring manufacturers in the world. Like many brands, they started small and only supplied carpet products. As the demand in the marketplace grew, so did they. Shaw began to provide a wide range of flooring products, including many popular choices like hardwood, laminate, and luxury vinyl flooring.

Shaw is also known for their flooring brand being a “Floor for any kind of budget.” They don’t consider themselves a luxury brand, but if you’re looking for a “step-up” for carpet products in terms of quality and design, they may still have what you’re looking for. Shaw Flooring owns a privately labeled brand called Anderson Tufftex. They are known for their solution-dyed nylon carpet products that last in commercial and residential settings.

But being a large company doesn’t automatically mean good or bad, so you should still know the advantages and disadvantages of working with Shaw, so you can see if they fit your needs. So let’s dive in!

Advantages of Shaw Flooring Products


1. Commitment to sustainability

Shaw Flooring is passionate about its eco-friendly manufacturing process. They have taken strides and implemented strategies to minimize its environmental impact. Shaw has a unique recycling system to reduce waste and promotes better practices in their supply chain. Sustainability is always a great goal, and our entire team at Flooring Solutions appreciates these initiatives.

2. Long-standing Reputation

Shaw Flooring has been in business since 1949. They quickly rose to the top of the global flooring manufacturer’s due to their great customer service, testimonials, and quality products.

3. Various different floor coverings

Options, options, options! Shaw Flooring has thousands of products lines available in all of their flooring categories. They are consistently sourcing new materials and producing up-to-date product lines to fit in with design trends.

4. Local Shipping Methods

Wait times for your products are significantly shorter than some manufacturers who ship from the West Coast. Though it’s not always possible to ship more locally, Shaw does an excellent job keeping available inventory.

5. Technology Innovation

Shaw Flooring uses a virtual reality type technology that allows you to visualize flooring products in your room by simply uploading a photo. The software uses your room to digitally place the flooring you selected onto your photo, giving you an idea of how it would look in your space.

shaw floors


What are the Disadvantages of Shaw Flooring Products?

1. Limited availability

Certain styles and product lines may only be available to vendors and flooring retail stores. This means you may be unable to purchase it from big box stores, and if you need access to a local flooring store near you, it could present some challenges in availability.

2. Installation challenges:

Depending on the style, product-specific installation guidelines may not be ideal for your home. For example, if you fell in love with engineered hardwood flooring, but one of the installation requirements was using a recommended glue. If that glue is unavailable, it may cause you to use a different, non-recommended glue and face some challenges during the installation process


Schedule Shaw Flooring Consultation

Who is Mohawk Industries?

Mohawk is another major player in the flooring game! They also operate and manufacture flooring all over the world. Whereas Shaw is known for its carpet products, Mohawk is more widely known for its resilient products, which are laminate and luxury vinyl plank. These products have grown increasingly popular over the years, and Mohawk has been innovative in keeping up with the marketplace’s demand.

Mohawk flooring has product lines that work well in commercial and residential settings. From carpet to hardwood, they offer many different price points and styles. Like Shaw’s private label brand, Mohawk has one of its own. Karastan Commercial carpet is their own privately labeled flooring brand designed to meet the needs of commercial customers interested in carpets.

Before knowing if Mohawk Industries fits your flooring needs, we will explore some advantages and disadvantages below, and you can decide for yourself.

What are the Advantages of Mohawk Flooring Products?

1. Reputable Quality

Along with its eco-friendly manufacturing process, Mohawk has a lasting reputation for producing products that perform well over time. They definitely appeal to homeowners and listened to the frustrations and demands of the marketplace with flooring not holding up.

2. Availability

Mohawk Industries doesn’t exclusively focus on one product over the other. They offer anywhere from carpet and hardwood, to commercial-grade products. This means you are very likely to find a product that matches your design and personal style.

3. Customer Service

With a company as large as Mohawk Industries, an emphasis is placed on customer support. Mohawk is known to have a great claim-processing system and customer service team. When you or the professional flooring company you purchased your product from need support, Mohawk has a reputation for being there for its customers.

4. Manufacturing process

Mohawk sources raw materials from all over the world. These materials are carefully selected to ensure they are of the right quality for their customers. Another feature they implement is a quality control program throughout the manufacturing process. Products are tested for durability, color, and performance.

5. Affordability

Mohawk is known for its affordable products that fit any budget. Mohawk has a huge product inventory, some of which offer premium features and warranties. Flooring Solutions appreciates working with Mohawk due to its affordability even with its higher-end products.

Disadvantages of Mohawk Flooring Products

1. Maintenance concerns

Like with many flooring brands and manufacturers, there are limitations where you should install their products. Some Mohawk flooring products may require additional maintenance, such as professional cleaning or sealing. This especially matters if you install Mohawk flooring in high-traffic areas, as it can be prone to scratches if not correctly maintained.

2. Style Options:

This doesn’t quite sound like a disadvantage, right? Some flooring manufacturers are not sold directly to the public. You have to purchase through a vendor, like Flooring Solutions. While Mohawk certainly has exclusive product lines that customers can only access through vendor relationships, they also have product lines easily found online and in big box stores that can be sold to the public. This might take away from the exclusivity and uniqueness of your flooring.

Finance kitchen floors

Finance new kitchen floors

Schedule Mohawk Flooring Consultation

Which Flooring Company is Best For Me?

As your research has likely told you, there is no clear answer to which company is best. Both companies have pros and cons, but in the end, it will come down to what matters most to you. Shaw Flooring and Mohawk have similar products that appeal to different needs and prices. That is the beauty of both brands, and why we want to help guide you to a wise decision.

There isn’t a “right” choice, only what’s right for you. If you’re still unsure what exactly is right for you, Flooring Solutions can help you dive deeper into your lifestyle needs. Discovering your family’s needs looks like determining how much traffic you have, any accidental spills from kids or pets, and figuring out what your overall style ideas are.

So, what styles, designs, and color options are best for your flooring project?

Knowing these facts helps us advise you on which flooring company will provide you with the best results. We highly recommend scheduling your free design consultation where we thoroughly cover these topics.

Book Your Design Consultation